Long time thief player, I've been back to thief since the black parade released, it's 2024 and I keep finding thief FM gems.
What an amazing community!

This campaign fits perfectly between thief 1 and 2.
I did not mind the re-use of maps, as there is alway something a bit different, and it serves the story so well.
Very clever how all the stories are all connected, I recommend reading everything properly.

FMs can sometimes be too hard and bordeline impossible without a walkthrough/hints but the difficulty here was OK, the wailing keep is the only level that annoyed me, it wasn't clear what to do and enmies are relentless, hindering exploration.

I also like the scale of the map, some can be overwhelming, too convoluted or too big, this was great.

Overall this is a brilliant campaign!